Blog – Articles

By Fr. Michael Stogre S.J.

After 22 years assigned to the native apostolate in Northern Ontario I have been missioned  to a different ministry (university chaplaincy) in Vancouver, B.C.. Prior to that I had worked at the Jesuit Centre for Social Faith & Justice. There I already had contact with native peoples and issues.  For example, I represented the Jesuits on Project North, an ecumenical coalition, that supported native people in their quest for justice–especially in the area of land claims. I also  worked on native health issues with the Union of Ontario Indians. These involvements continued as I pursued research for a doctorate in Christian ethics. My topic was papal teaching on aboriginal rights.

All of these interests and involvements followed me North to the Anishinabe Spiritual Centre where I completed my dissertation and defended it in 1992. As the years went by pastoral work became dominant as I served several native parishes (Our Lady of the Highway, St. Raphael’s, St Gabriel Lalemant, Immaculate Conception & it’s satellite missions at Mindemoya, Gore Bay, & Sheshegwaning).

At the same time–like many of the Jesuits–I got involved with the ministries program. From a program designed to revive the diaconate it became a formation effort for both men and women. Two of our male candidates for the diaconate went on to study for the priesthood. These were Frs. Milton McWatch and George Gardner who still serve the church in Northern Ontario.

Nineteen women have been commissioned for the Diocesan Order of Service; they are really deacons in all but name. Their time may soon come again–as the church now seems to be open to discussing a female diaconate–as we had in the early centuries of the Church. Our hope and our goal remains a native church that is a self-governing, self-sufficient, and self-propagating local faith community. If this is to happen a new and younger generation of native church leaders need to be identified, recruited, trained, and  missioned.  

As I look back over my years in the North, and over my earlier years working with native people on health and justice issues, the biggest change in band and church life has been the tremendous growth in local leadership capability. From a time when the Indian agent and Indian affairs ran everything – and permission had to be asked to even leave the reserve there has been tremendous change.  From a time when the resident  or visiting  parish priest controlled parish life  and governance there has been a huge shift to local control. 

I witnessed this firsthand in my first years in the North as I  worked on the health transfer process.  In this case,  Health and Welfare Canada and Indian Affairs transferred control of health matters to the local bands and tribal councils. In a number of parishes where I have worked e.g. on the Serpent River & Sagamok reserves Deacons, for example,  have been appointed administrators of these parishes.

There has also been a greater openness to the wider ecumenism–that is to go beyond efforts to understand and work with Christians of other denominations to also accommodate traditional native practices where appropriate in the Liturgy.  This has been growing especially at funeral services in many places. Efforts have also been made to “inculturate” the faith–that is to express the Christian faith  in the forms of the local culture. This now happens in small ways at masses where the penance rite for example often includes a smudging ceremony and the sacred medicines of cedar, sage, tobacco and sweet grass replace the use of the venerable incense–or are added to it.

While there are hymns sung in Ojibway there is  no one at the present time able to say Mass in the vernacular native tongue of this area–nor is there an authorized translation in Ojibway of Eucharistic and other  Mass

prayers. Even if such texts existed, many in the local first nations would not be able to understand them. Ecumenism and inculturation have a long way  to go. But perhaps the native penchant to sing in country and western style is telling us that the real issues of inculturation need to be faced by the dominant catholic culture as well. Going back to Latin and Gregorian chant is not going to cut it in first nations communities or in Canada generally.

Before bringing  this reflection  to a close I must beg pardon of the many unnamed and unheralded priests, brothers, sisters, lay collaborators and local diocesan personnel who carried on, and supported this ministry since the return of the Jesuits in 1842.  Jesuit records reveal that nearly one hundred Jesuit priests, who lived and died in the Society of Jesus, served the native apostolate for a time–or a life time.  At least forty-three brothers also served in this ministry for some or all of their Jesuit lives. Their rewards in this life were few.

There are also some loose ends that need to be mentioned in passing. First, the urban native apostolate  existed for a time in several places, and continues to exist in Thunder Bay.  Dan Hannin S.J., while studying Sociology in Regina, helped to organize Wikiup, an incipient native parish, in that city. It has now been closed. Also in Regina the Reverend John Matheson pioneered an outreach to native prisoners. It is called “Friends on the outside,” a good example of Jesuit and lay collaboration in a social ministry. Fr. Douglas McCarthy S.J. who later worked full time in native ministry out of Wikwemikong did prison ministry in Guelph. There he helped bring native culture and spirituality into the prison system itself, and at the Ignatius farm community. 

The administrative staff at Campion College, especially the late Peter Nash S.J., gave quiet but unstinting support to the First Nations University in that city–especially during its start up period.  Barnie  Mayhew S.J., after a long ministry in Northern Ontario, began the native peoples parish in Toronto which continues to this day.  St. Ignatius parish in Winnipeg supported the Sisters of Zion in their efforts at educating native children in that city.

On a different front the Alaska mission was attached to the Canadian province for a few years.  This happened in 1907, the year the Canadian Jesuits formed their own province. This arrangement lasted five years after which the mission was transferred to the California province of the

Society of Jesus.  Another Jesuit who worked outside the Upper Canada Province native mission territory was the Reverend Gordon Bazinet S.J.  After working at Akwesasne, the Mohawk reserve near Cornwall, Ontario, he returned to the Northern Ontario missions and was tragically killed in a car accident.

The social justice and human rights work, so prominent in the early years of the  mission, was carried on through the Jesuit Centre for Social Faith and Justice based in Toronto. Working ecumenically through Project North, later renamed the Aboriginal Rights Coalition, and finally, subsumed under Kairos, the Churches’ umbrella social justice group, the Jesuits in English Canada worked on land claims and other native human rights issues. Some Jesuits in Northern Ontario–like George Leach and Bernie Carroll–were also involved with land claims issues at Bear Island on Lake Temagami.  Carroll is now the Director of The Martyr’s Shrine in Midland Ontario. There the Jesuit staff have taken up the pastoral care of the native Catholic community on nearby Christian island. They also welcome native pilgrims to their annual June prayer days.

The recent canonization of St. Kateri Tekakwitha will no doubt energize this Jesuit outreach to native peoples from around Ontario and beyond. While the Kanawake parish where Kateri is buried was the responsibility of the French Canadian province,  English speaking Jesuits from Loyola often supplied there, and students from the Mohawk reserve attended Loyola High School and College. 

I should also mention here the painstaking work of Bill Maurice S.J.  He collected  and searched through church records so that native family trees could be reconstructed. This work often helped individuals, families, communities,  reclaim their native status and rights. Maurice and Hannin were also involved in early economic development work in some native communities.

Conclusion: 

It has been said that pastoral ministry goes on till “the end of the age,” (Matt: 28-20) while “evangelization” should be over and done with in a reasonable amount of time.  This seems to have been the  Pauline  approach.  St. Paul, after preaching the Gospel in a city or town, and after converting a critical mass of the population, would appoint leaders in, from, and for, each community. He would then, like Jesus,  move on to the other towns that had not yet heard the Gospel.  However, Paul never envisaged the time when a new, second, or re-evangelization would be needed in vast areas of a once Christianized world.  That is now our situation.